top of page

10 Hidden Gems: Discover Bay County's Best Neighborhoods

Updated: Aug 6, 2023

Bay County, Florida is home to some of the best neighborhoods in the area, but many people are unaware of the hidden gems that can be found here. From waterfront views to small-town charm, Bay County has a variety of neighborhoods that offer something for everyone. Whether you’re looking for a cozy retirement community or a family-friendly neighborhood, you’re sure to find something to love in Bay County. In this blog post, we’ll be exploring the top 10 neighborhoods in Bay County, so you can start your search and discover the perfect place to call home.


The Selection Process

To choose the top 10 neighborhoods in Bay County, Florida, we considered several factors, including location, safety, affordability, school district, demographics, amenities, future development, and real estate market trends. We conducted extensive research on each neighborhood, analyzing data on crime rates, school districts, median home prices, and demographic makeup. We also considered the availability of amenities such as shopping, dining, and recreational activities, as well as the potential for future development in each neighborhood. Finally, we looked at real estate market trends, including housing prices and sales volume, to determine which neighborhoods were experiencing the most growth and demand. By carefully considering all of these factors, we were able to select the top 10 neighborhoods in Bay County, Florida, that offer the best quality of life for residents.


Home in Mexico Beach, FL
Mexico Beach, Florida

Mexico Beach

Mexico Beach is a charming seaside town located in Bay County, Florida, along the Gulf of Mexico. It's situated in the Florida Panhandle, about 25 miles east of Panama City Beach and 100 miles southwest of Tallahassee. The town is known for its picturesque beaches, crystal-clear waters, and laid-back lifestyle. Mexico Beach is a relatively safe community, with a crime rate that is lower than the national average.


The cost of living in Mexico Beach is affordable compared to other beach towns in Florida. The median home value is around $300,000, which is reasonable given the town's desirable location. The school district serving Mexico Beach is Bay District Schools, which is known for its high-quality education and exceptional teachers. Demographically, Mexico Beach has a population of around 1,200, with a median age of 60. The town has a significant retirement community, and many residents are second-home owners.


Mexico Beach offers several amenities, including beach access, fishing, boating, and water sports. The town has a few local restaurants, shops, and cafes, and it's just a short drive away from larger cities like Panama City Beach and Port St. Joe. Mexico Beach is an up-and-coming area, with several future development projects in the works. There are plans to revitalize the downtown area, add more dining and shopping options, and improve public beach access. The real estate market in Mexico Beach is currently experiencing high demand, with limited inventory and rising prices. Despite the effects of Hurricane Michael in 2018, the town is bouncing back and attracting new residents and investors.


Home in Laguna Beach, FL
Laguna Beach, Florida

Laguna Beach

Laguna Beach is a small coastal community situated in Bay County, Florida, on the eastern edge of Panama City Beach. The town is known for its breathtaking white-sand beaches, crystal-clear waters, and laid-back atmosphere. It's located just a few miles west of Panama City Beach, and about 100 miles southwest of Tallahassee. Laguna Beach is a relatively safe community, with a low crime rate and friendly residents.


The cost of living in Laguna Beach is affordable compared to other beach towns in Florida. The median home value is around $400,000, which is reasonable given the town's desirable location. The school district serving Laguna Beach is Bay District Schools, which provides high-quality education and excellent teachers. Demographically, Laguna Beach has a population of around 5,000, with a median age of 52. The town has a mix of full-time residents and vacation homeowners.


Laguna Beach offers several amenities, including beach access, fishing, boating, and water sports. The town has a few local restaurants, shops, and cafes, and it's just a short drive away from larger cities like Panama City Beach and Destin. The town is currently experiencing a wave of future development, with several projects in the works to enhance the community's infrastructure and amenities. The real estate market in Laguna Beach is currently experiencing high demand, with limited inventory and rising prices. Despite the effects of Hurricane Michael in 2018, the town is bouncing back and attracting new residents and investors.


Home in Inlet Beach, FL
Inlet Beach, Florida

Inlet Beach

Inlet Beach is a beautiful coastal community located in the Florida Panhandle, just east of Destin and west of Panama City Beach. It is known for its stunning white sand beaches, clear turquoise waters, and peaceful atmosphere. Inlet Beach is situated in close proximity to several popular attractions such as Rosemary Beach, Seaside, and Grayton Beach, making it an ideal location for tourists and locals alike. Safety is a top priority in Inlet Beach, with low crime rates and a strong sense of community.


Inlet Beach is a relatively affordable area compared to other nearby beach communities. The school districts serving the area are Bay District Schools and Walton County School District, which is known for its high-quality education system. The demographic makeup of Inlet Beach is primarily made up of families, retirees, and vacationers. There are plenty of amenities in Inlet Beach, including shopping, dining, and recreational activities. The community is also home to several parks, trails, and nature reserves, which offer a variety of outdoor activities such as hiking, biking, and bird-watching.


In terms of future development, Inlet Beach is expected to continue to grow and expand over the coming years. Several new residential and commercial developments are in the works, including new restaurants, shops, and housing developments. As a result, the real estate market in Inlet Beach is expected to remain strong, with prices continuing to rise over time. Overall, Inlet Beach is a beautiful and thriving community that offers a fantastic quality of life for those who choose to call it home.


Home in West Bay, FL
West Bay, Florida

West Bay

West Bay is a small unincorporated community located in Bay County, Florida. It is situated on the northern shore of West Bay, a natural inlet that connects to the Gulf of Mexico. West Bay offers a laid-back, small-town atmosphere and is within close proximity to larger cities like Panama City and Destin. In terms of safety, West Bay has a low crime rate, making it a desirable location for families and retirees alike. Additionally, the area is relatively affordable compared to other coastal communities in Florida.


West Bay is served by the Bay District Schools, which includes several highly-rated public schools in the surrounding area. The demographics of West Bay are diverse, with a mix of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors. The area attracts a wide range of people due to its proximity to the beach, natural beauty, and outdoor recreation opportunities.


Despite being a smaller community, West Bay offers a variety of amenities such as local restaurants, shops, and recreational activities. For example, the nearby Panama City Beach offers world-class beaches and water activities, while the West Bay Wildlife Management Area provides opportunities for hiking, birdwatching, and fishing.


Looking to the future, West Bay is poised for growth and development. There are plans for a new airport and commercial development, which could attract new businesses and residents to the area. This development could also drive real estate market trends in the coming years. Currently, the real estate market in West Bay is steady, with a mix of both single-family homes and vacation rentals available for purchase. Overall, West Bay offers a tranquil and affordable coastal living experience with plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation and growth potential in the future.


Home in Upper Grand Lagoon, FL
Upper Grand Lagoon, FL

Upper Grand Lagoon

Upper Grand Lagoon is a small community located in Bay County, Florida, just east of Panama City Beach. It is situated on St. Andrews Bay, providing residents with easy access to water activities like fishing, boating, and kayaking. The location is also convenient for those who work or attend school in nearby cities like Panama City or Lynn Haven. In terms of safety, Upper Grand Lagoon has a low crime rate, making it a desirable location for families and retirees.


Upper Grand Lagoon is served by the Bay District Schools, which includes several highly-rated public schools in the surrounding area. The demographics of Upper Grand Lagoon are diverse, with a mix of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors. The area attracts a wide range of people due to its proximity to the beach, natural beauty, and outdoor recreation opportunities.


Despite being a smaller community, Upper Grand Lagoon offers a variety of amenities such as local restaurants, shops, and recreational activities. The community is home to several parks and public beach access points, as well as a variety of locally-owned businesses. Additionally, the nearby Panama City Beach offers world-class beaches and attractions like amusement parks and shopping centers.


Looking to the future, Upper Grand Lagoon is poised for growth and development. There are plans for a new airport and commercial development, which could attract new businesses and residents to the area. This development could also drive real estate market trends in the coming years. Currently, the real estate market in Upper Grand Lagoon is steady, with a mix of both single-family homes and vacation rentals available for purchase. Overall, Upper Grand Lagoon offers a peaceful and affordable coastal living experience with plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation and growth potential in the future.


Home in Lynn Haven FL
Lynn Haven, Florida

Lynn Haven

Lynn Haven is a city located in Bay County, Florida, just north of Panama City. The city is situated on the shores of North Bay and is conveniently located near major highways, making it easy to access nearby cities like Panama City Beach and Destin. Lynn Haven is known for its small-town charm and close-knit community, making it a desirable location for families and retirees. In terms of safety, Lynn Haven has a relatively low crime rate compared to other cities in Florida.


Lynn Haven is served by the Bay District Schools, which includes several highly-rated public schools in the surrounding area. The demographics of Lynn Haven are diverse, with a mix of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors. The area attracts a wide range of people due to its proximity to the beach, natural beauty, and outdoor recreation opportunities.


Despite being a smaller city, Lynn Haven offers a variety of amenities such as local restaurants, shops, and recreational activities. The city is home to several parks and public beach access points, as well as a variety of locally-owned businesses. Additionally, the nearby Panama City Beach offers world-class beaches and attractions like amusement parks and shopping centers.


Looking to the future, Lynn Haven is poised for growth and development. There are plans for new commercial development, which could attract new businesses and residents to the area. This development could also drive real estate market trends in the coming years. Currently, the real estate market in Lynn Haven is steady, with a mix of both single-family homes and townhomes available for purchase. Overall, Lynn Haven offers a friendly and affordable living experience with plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation and growth potential in the future.


Home in Bayou George, FL
Bayou George, Florida

Bayou George

Bayou George is a small unincorporated community located in Bay County, Florida. It is situated just north of Panama City and is known for its quiet, rural atmosphere. Bayou George is surrounded by natural beauty, including nearby lakes and forests, making it a popular location for outdoor recreation. In terms of safety, Bayou George has a relatively low crime rate compared to other areas in Florida.


Bayou George is served by the Bay District Schools, which includes several highly-rated public schools in the surrounding area. The demographics of Bayou George are diverse, with a mix of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors. The area attracts a wide range of people due to its proximity to the beach, natural beauty, and affordable cost of living.


Despite being a smaller community, Bayou George offers a variety of amenities such as local restaurants, shops, and recreational activities. The area is home to several parks and outdoor recreation areas, as well as a variety of locally-owned businesses. Additionally, the nearby city of Panama City offers access to world-class beaches and attractions like amusement parks and shopping centers.


Looking to the future, Bayou George is poised for growth and development. There are plans for new commercial development, which could attract new businesses and residents to the area. This development could also drive real estate market trends in the coming years. Currently, the real estate market in Bayou George is steady, with a mix of both single-family homes and mobile homes available for purchase. Overall, Bayou George offers a peaceful and affordable living experience with plenty of opportunities for outdoor recreation and growth potential in the future.


Home in Historic St. Andrews FL
Historic St. Andrews, Florida

Historic St. Andrews

St. Andrews is a historic neighborhood located in Panama City, Florida, on the shores of St. Andrews Bay. The area is known for its charming architecture and lively atmosphere, with plenty of restaurants, shops, and attractions to explore. St. Andrews is also home to a vibrant fishing community, with many opportunities for water activities like fishing, boating, and kayaking. In terms of safety, St. Andrews has a relatively low crime rate compared to other areas in Florida.


St. Andrews is served by the Bay District Schools, which includes several highly-rated public schools in the surrounding area. The demographics of St. Andrews are diverse, with a mix of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors. The area attracts a wide range of people due to its proximity to the beach, natural beauty, and unique character.


St. Andrews offers a wide variety of amenities, including local shops, restaurants, and attractions like the St. Andrews State Park and the Panama City Marina. The neighborhood is also home to a thriving arts community, with many galleries and studios showcasing the work of local artists. Additionally, the nearby Panama City Beach offers access to world-class beaches and attractions like amusement parks and shopping centers.


Looking to the future, St. Andrews is poised for growth and development. There are plans for new commercial development, which could attract new businesses and residents to the area. This development could also drive real estate market trends in the coming years. Currently, the real estate market in St. Andrews is steady, with a mix of both single-family homes and condos available for purchase. Overall, St. Andrews offers a vibrant and affordable living experience with plenty of opportunities for culture, recreation, and growth potential in the future.


Home in Carillon Beach FL
Carillon Beach, Florida

Carillon Beach

Carillon Beach is a stunning gated community located on the western end of Panama City Beach, Florida. The community sits along the pristine beaches of the Gulf of Mexico, offering breathtaking views and a serene atmosphere. Carillon Beach is a safe and secure community, with 24-hour security and gated entry. Crime rates in the area are low, and the community is known for its friendly and welcoming residents.


While Carillon Beach may be more expensive compared to other beach communities in the area, it offers a high-quality education system through the Bay District School District. The community is popular among families and retirees, and the demographics are primarily made up of middle to upper-class residents. Amenities in Carillon Beach are abundant, with several restaurants, shops, and recreational activities available to residents and visitors. The community is also home to a large park, several swimming pools, and a community center.


Carillon Beach has seen significant development in recent years, with several new housing and commercial developments in the works. The community is expected to continue to grow and expand, with several new restaurants and shops opening in the near future. As a result, the real estate market in Carillon Beach is expected to remain strong, with prices continuing to rise over time. Overall, Carillon Beach is a beautiful and upscale community that offers a luxurious beach lifestyle for those who choose to call it home.


Home at Bid-A-Wee, FL
Bid-A-Wee Beach, Florida

Bid-A-Wee Beach

Bid-A-Wee Beach is a small beach community located in Panama City Beach, Florida. It is situated on the eastern edge of Panama City Beach and is known for its secluded and uncrowded beach access. Bid-A-Wee Beach is a gated community, that provides a high level of safety and security for residents and visitors alike. In terms of affordability, Bid-A-Wee Beach has a higher cost of living compared to other areas in the region due to its exclusive nature.


Bid-A-Wee Beach is served by the Bay District Schools, which includes several highly-rated public schools in the surrounding area. The demographics of Bid-A-Wee Beach are diverse, with a mix of both permanent residents and seasonal visitors. The area attracts a wide range of people due to its proximity to the beach and exclusive nature.


Despite being a small community, Bid-A-Wee Beach offers a variety of amenities such as beach access, a community pool, and nearby golf courses. Additionally, the nearby city of Panama City Beach offers access to world-class beaches and attractions like amusement parks and shopping centers.


Looking to the future, Bid-A-Wee Beach is poised for limited growth and development. Due to its exclusive nature, development is limited to existing properties, making real estate market trends stable but exclusive. Currently, the real estate market in Bid-A-Wee Beach is focused on single-family homes and condos, with limited availability. Overall, Bid-A-Wee Beach offers an exclusive and secluded living experience with access to world-class amenities and limited potential for growth.


Contact a Paradisum Group Realtor to Learn More

If you’re interested in learning more about some of Bay County, Florida’s top neighborhoods and real estate opportunities, contact Paradisum Group brokered by Anchor Realty Florida.


Our experienced team of local real estate agents can provide you with insight into the best neighborhoods in Bay County, and guide you through the process of finding your perfect home. With our expertise, you can be sure that your experience with Florida real estate will be both stress-free and successful. For more information on how Paradisum Group can help you find your dream home in Bay County, don’t hesitate to reach out today!


If you're considering buying a house or investment property in the Florida real estate market, let our Realtors® at Paradisum Group brokered by Anchor Realty Florida help you make a sound decision today!


Paradise Awaits You! CALL Paradisum Group at 850-320-8385 Today!

Paradise Awaits - eXperience the Difference with Paradisum Group eXp
bottom of page